Back to Blog

Tenants · 2 min read

Choosing tenants with confidence: what to look for.

DM

Dean MacFarlane

Published 4 February 2026 · 2 min read · Updated 5 October 2026

Supporting documents, affordability and credit history help build a clearer picture of a prospective tenant.

A considered tenancy starts with understanding the application. Supporting documents, affordability and credit history give a landlord more information to work with. The value comes from understanding the picture they form together and asking useful questions about anything that needs clarification.

Look at the application in context

Check that the application and supporting records tell a consistent story. Where information is missing or unclear, ask for clarification before reaching a conclusion. Keep the discussion relevant to the tenancy and handle the applicant’s personal information with care.

Income information helps you consider affordability alongside the proposed rent and other commitments. Different applicants may have different income patterns, so a headline figure alone may not explain their circumstances. Supporting documents help put that figure in context.

Treat credit history as one part of the picture

A credit report can add useful information about financial commitments and payment history. Read it alongside the rest of the application rather than treating one score as a complete answer. A discrepancy is a reason to understand the available information more carefully, not to invent an explanation.

Neither paperwork nor an interview can guarantee how a tenancy will unfold. A clear assessment gives the landlord a basis for a considered decision and a record of the questions discussed.

Make references useful

Where references form part of the assessment, agree an appropriate way to obtain and check them. Keep questions factual and relevant: the tenancy period, payment history and condition of the property at handover can help explain the previous tenancy. Give the applicant an opportunity to clarify conflicting information.

Avoid replacing documented information with assumptions about how somebody looks or speaks. A consistent assessment is easier to understand and discuss than a decision based on a vague impression.

Keep the landlord involved

A useful recommendation explains the information reviewed, the points that need attention and the proposed next step. You can ask questions and stay involved in deciding who will rent your property.

Once a tenant is selected, lease preparation, signing coordination and move-in arrangements help organise the start of the tenancy. A documented inspection creates a useful record of the property’s condition for the people involved.

MPG brings care to tenant assessment and structure to the administration that follows. Tell us about your rental to discuss the support you need.

DM

Dean MacFarlane

Dean MacFarlane is the founder of MacFarlane Property Group. His hands-on approach brings tenant assessment, rental administration and clear communication together for landlords in Cape Town, Mbombela and Johannesburg.

Want this kind of management for your property?

Free assessment, honest numbers, no obligation.

Get a free assessment
Back to Blog